Guardians

2026

#14 of 30Average· .503 vs. an average team· team strength

Record

85-77 .525

xRecord · simulator

81-81 +3.8 vs expected

Grade · runs scored / allowed

OffenseD-·PitchingB

Snapshot

Three cards cover the record, the run differential and how lucky the team has been.

Identity

Guardians85-77

The offense is elite on contact and bottom-tier on quality. The pitching is elite on strikeouts and weak on quiet contact.

Run differential

+11 run diff

They score 4.2 runs a game and allow 4.1, against a league average of 4.5. The pitching is the bigger reason.

Luck

3.8 wins above expected

The simulator says their game-by-game play deserved 81.2 wins. They have 85.

Team identity

See where the team ranks among all 30 on runs and on four hitting and pitching rates.

Offense style

This lineup rarely barrels the ball and pulls the ball a lot.

These strips compare how this lineup hits the ball with the other 29 teams. Pull rate and fly-ball rate are a style, not a skill, but a higher barrel rate is better.

Pull rate42.0% · 6th of 30 · Pulls a lot

34.7%43.5%

Fly-ball rate23.4% · 12th of 30 · Mixed

19.4%26.0%

Barrel rate5.2% · 30th of 30 · Few barrels

5.2%8.8%

Guardiansone teamLg median

Hitters

Every hitter with 25 or more plate appearances is ranked here, with a 50% probable range.

This lineup is balanced. Its top 3 hitters account for +383 bases above replacement, and the other 17 combine for +610.

Hitters by estimated bases per plate appearance (EB/PA)

Lg median
(0.430)

0.3430.4290.5150.6010.687

← WorseBetter →

Best estimate50% probable rangeLeague best: Aaron Judge (0.687)

How to read this chart

The dot is the simulator's best estimate. The bar around it covers the middle 50% of where that estimate could land. A short bar means a lot of evidence, and a long one means the sample is still thin.
Where two players' bars overlap, the simulator cannot honestly separate them, however far apart their ranks are.
The tinted halves split at the dashed league median, with the better side green and the worse side red.
The dashed median and the teal league-best line cover the whole league, not just these players.
Click any player to open his page.

BB% vs HR%

League best:BB% Davis Schneider (18.6%)HR% Hunter Goodman (7.1%)

A bigger dot means more strikeouts, which is worse for a hitter.

How to read this chart

Each face is one player on this roster, with BB% across the bottom and HR% up the side, both as a share of the plate appearances he took.
Higher is better on both, so the best hitters sit top-right.
The dashed lines are the league-wide rates this season, so a corner means better or worse than the league, not than a teammate.
Tap a headshot to open the player.Hover a headshot for the player.
The league best is named above the chart, among hitters with 50 or more plate appearances. More on the About page

1 more hitter has fewer than 25 plate appearances, too few to rank:

Cooper Ingle (24 PA)

Pitchers

Every pitcher with 40 or more batters faced is ranked here, with a 50% probable range.

This staff is star-led. Its top 3 pitchers account for +189 bases above replacement, and the other 17 combine for +59.

Pitchers by estimated bases allowed per plate appearance (xEB/PA)

Lg median
(0.454)

0.3670.3990.4310.4640.496

← BetterWorse →

Best estimate50% probable rangeLeague best: Jacob Misiorowski (0.367)

How to read this chart

The dot is the simulator's best estimate. The bar around it covers the middle 50% of where that estimate could land. A short bar means a lot of evidence, and a long one means the sample is still thin.
Where two players' bars overlap, the simulator cannot honestly separate them, however far apart their ranks are.
The tinted halves split at the dashed league median, with the better side green and the worse side red.
The dashed median and the teal league-best line cover the whole league, not just these players.
Click any player to open his page.

BB% allowed vs HR% allowed

League best:BB% allowed Bryse Wilson (3.7%)HR% allowed Blake Snell (0.0%)

A bigger dot means more strikeouts, which is better for a pitcher.

How to read this chart

Each face is one player on this roster, with BB% allowed across the bottom and HR% allowed up the side, both as a share of the batters he faced.
Lower is better on both, so the best pitchers sit bottom-left.
The dashed lines are the league-wide rates this season, so a corner means better or worse than the league, not than a teammate.
Tap a headshot to open the player.Hover a headshot for the player.
The league best is named above the chart, among pitchers with 100 or more batters faced. More on the About page

3 more pitchers have fewer than 40 batters faced, too few to rank:

Season value

This puts every ranked hitter and pitcher on one scale, bases above replacement.

+1240

bases above replacement · 23rd of 30 teams · from 20 hitters and 20 pitchers

Who carried the team

Bars to the right helped the team more than a replacement player would have.

Above replacement

Chase DeLauter Hitter

117

Travis Bazzana Hitter

Rhys Hoskins Hitter

Parker Messick Starter

Kyle Manzardo Hitter

Brayan Rocchio Hitter

Gavin Williams Starter

Tanner Bibee Starter

Below replacement

Erik Sabrowski Reliever

-10

Peyton Pallette Reliever

-9

Shawn Armstrong Reliever

-9

Craig Yoho Reliever

-9

Colin Holderman Reliever

-5

Franco Aleman Reliever

-4

Replacement level

How to read this chart

Each bar is one hitter's bat or one pitcher's arm, measured in bases above or below a freely available replacement player. Longer to the right is better. The tag marks the role: Hitter, Starter or Reliever.
The rates behind each bar are the simulator's estimates, the same ones the rankings above use, and a two-way player appears once for his bat and once for his arm.
The total adds up the whole roster, while this board shows the 10 biggest gains and the 6 biggest drags. Click a name for his page.

Recent games

These are the team's last 10 games. Playoff games are included and tagged Postseason. Click into any one to see the full simulator breakdown.

See all Guardians games →